Bill’s Bizarre Bijou
William D. Carl
This Week’s Feature Presentation:
SCREAM OF THE BUTTERFLY (1965)
Welcome to Bill’s Bizarre Bijou, where you’ll discover the strangest films ever made. If there are alien women with too much eye-shadow and miniskirts, if papier-mâché monsters are involved, if your local drive-in insisted this be the last show in their dusk till dawn extravaganza, or if it’s just plain unclassifiable—then I’ve seen it and probably loved it. Now, I’m here to share these little gems with you so you too can stare in disbelief at your television with your mouth dangling open. Trust me, with these flicks, you won’t believe your eyes.
This week we’re watching a wonderfully demented sex-noir from 1965, SCREAM OF THE BUTTERFLY. Boy howdy, this one starts with a bang! A blonde with a bouffant screams and practically spits at the camera, “Why I ever left Paul for you, I’ll never know. You degenerate! You’ll pay.” A voice shouts, “I’m warning you Marla…” The blonde moves into the driveway, where someone puts a car in gear and promptly runs her down. Cue the credits running over footage from the film we’re about to witness and beautiful lush music. Lush music suddenly transforms into wild jazz over footage of go-go dancers (this jarring shift in tone will be indicative of the movie we’re about to see). Wonder of wonders, the director is also the choreographer – Eber Lobato, and the movie stars his wife Nelida Lobato. And the cameraman was Ray Dennis Steckler, director of such ignominious features as THE INCREDIBLY STRANGE CREATURES WHO STOPPED LIVING AND BECAME MIXED-UP ZOMBIES (1964), THE THRILL KILLERS (1964), and RAT PFINK A BOO BOO (1966)
Back to our sordid tale – a handsome Adonis is arrested by the coppers while an older man watches. Marla is body-bagged and we are suddenly in a lawyer’s office and a whole new film stock. They speak to Paul Williams, the husband not the star of PHANTOM OF THE PARADISE (1974). “This case has everything. A beautiful girl, a rich husband, a little punk who kills her with two witnesses, and still there is a chance for a real good defense.” They speak about justice and how this “sort of thing” should be exposed so the public can see it all. Cue flashbacks:
Boring schmuck and airplane magnate Paul Williams is seduced by statuesque Marla during a modeling session in front of one of his aircraft. After a whirlwind romance, they’re married, but before the bouquet lands, Marla’s stepping out with the always shirtless, achingly handsome David (Nic Navarro, star of 1963’s HOOTENANY HOOT) . What follows are several actually erotic love scenes on the beach, including a hot number with the pair rolling in the crashing surf during a thunderstorm, ala 1953’s FROM HERE TO ETERNITY (only Deborah Kerr never lost her bikini top!). During their dalliances, an older man, Christian, keeps appearing to make snide comments, and when we cut back to the DA, we hear him explain that Christian is the case and the star witness. Meanwhile, while chump of the year Paul plays golf and Christian lurks a bit, Marla frolics in a bubble bath and along the beach, tossing in just enough nudity to attain an ‘adults-only’ rating.
Back in the lawyer’s office, the arguments and hateful dialogue continue. “Marla was a crummy little tramp.” “I can bring in a creep from Los Angeles that’ll prove Jesus Christ was a manic depressive. Great, we’ll get him the chair.” They even refer to our heroine as “Miss Slutsy Wutsy.”
After more flashbacks involving a rocking band and several table dancing scenes, Marla cheats, Christian lurks, and the hotel lifeguard teaches Paul how to swim so he can surprise his wife later. And boy is it a surprise! Marla tries to kill Paul by taking him out in a boat and pushing him overboard. Little did she realize, her schnook husband would end up saving her when she’s struck on the head by the capsized vessel.
And it all comes back to Christian Deval, played by the film’s writer Alan J, Smith. A self-loathing homosexual entangled with several of the film’s characters, this flick predates THE BOYS IN THE BAND (1970) in more ways than one. Viewed through the lens of the mid-sixties, the film has a very dated, yet advanced-for-the-time philosophy on bisexuality, homosexuality and mental illness. Gays are both to be pitied and reviled, yet the film shows them in a somewhat sympathetic light.
SCREAM OF THE BUTTERFLY appears to be an unfinished movie by Eber Lobato, including all the flashback scenes. The scenes in the lawyer’s office were directed by Howard Veit, and they complete the story, even if in a different kind of film stock. But both segments contain similar hateful dialogue, crisp black and white photography, and, with the exception of William Turner as Paul (a crummy actor in every scene), pretty good acting. I especially like the conniving Nelida Lobato, whose every move is feral and seductive. Originally a dancer and singer from Argentina, Nelida really pulls off the femme fatale role. It’s too bad she never really acted again. Then again, nearly everyone in the movie or behind the camera never worked again. SCREAM OF THE BUTTERFLY has fallen into the pit of disappearing movies.
And it’s too bad, because the script is pretty terrific, full of wickedly sly innuendos and noir-ish winks. See the following examples:
1.
“It’s open and shut.”
“So’s a mousetrap. Doesn’t mean you catch a mouse every time it shuts.”
“But even if it misses, it makes a hell of a noise.”
2.
“So, she’s a tramp. That’s no reason to kill her.”
3.
“When last we saw the Virgin Queen, she was making love to my client on the beach.”
4.
“Paul Williams was aware his wife was athletic.”
“I don’t think he was aware of the breadth of her definition of athletics.”
5.
“That punk’s nothing but a male whore.”
6.
“As a lover you’re a mockery, and as a man you’re a cripple!”
A terrifically devious and deviant film-noir, SCREAM OF THE BUTTERFLY is a fabulous little movie that could’ve been a minor hit, but ended up an “adults-only”obscurity. The bit of nudity and the sexually-oriented material kept it hidden. Now, it should be rediscovered and given its due. I give it three and a half sexually-confused volleyball players out of four.
You can get a copy of SCREAM OF THE BUTTERFLY from Something Weird Video in a download or as the second feature on a DVD with DAY OF THE NIGHTMARE (also from 1965).
© Copyright 2011 by William D. Carl






















